When the time comes to installing a new roof, there are plenty of options to choose from. The first thing to know is that each material available has their advantages and disadvantages. Therefore, knowing these beforehand is extremely helpful. When picking the best material, its worth noting that not only style and color preference are important but also to pick the best protection for your home. This in turn will help avoid further costs down the road such as  repairs or other damages. Today, we are looking at the pros and cons of asphalt shingles as a roofing option.

When you are browsing for roofing options, its important to know what you currently have installed on top of your house. If you live in the Midwest, chances are that you have asphalt shingles currently on your house. Asphalt shingles are the most common type of shingle throughout the U.S. Sure, you may see some houses with metal roofs or tile but there are fewer of these in the Midwest. Asphalt shingle roofing has always been the top choice for many homeowners due to their prices, durability,etc.

Below, we are going further into some asphalt shingle details. We highlight some of the pros and cons of asphalt shingle roofing being installed in Indianapolis.


asphalt shingle installation brand new roof

Pros 0f Asphalt Shingles

Asphalt shingles are the most popular option for today’s homeowners. It is estimated that over 80% of asphalt shingles are used in roof installations and re-roofing projects throughout the country.

Let’s take a look at why this is the most popular material in the roofing industry. Some of the pros of asphalt shingles include:

  • Affordability – Possibly the #1 reason why asphalt shingles are so popular, their prices. Out of all the roofing materials on the market, asphalt shingles are the most affordable choice overall. This is the reason so many homeowners who are not looking to break the bank choose asphalt.
  • It’s durability – Asphalt shingles come with different tiers of durability and colors. The standard asphalt shingle will protect your roof from the elements, from harsh rainstorms to snow and extremely hot temperatures.
  • Variety at every corner – Its important to know that asphalt shingles come with different options as well. Standard shingles from most manufacturers will resist up to 110mph winds. A higher quality shingle will be able to resist 130mph winds and comes with additional add-ons. Asphalt shingles will also come in additional colors to choose from. And if you are looking for more aesthetically pleasing looks, asphalt also offers architectural higher-end shingles. Meaning, these shingles will have a different tile look than the standard rectangular shape and have more vibrant colors.
  • People like the look – When pertaining to your roof, if the option you are leaning towards is a more traditional look, then you have to pick asphalt shingles. As stated above, these are the most popular option, homeowners rely on asphalt shingle roofs to give their homes the classic, homey look for centuries past. Metal roofs or clay tiles are not for some people and that’s okay. Simple yet effective is a great way to go, so choose asphalt shingles.
  • The installation process – Asphalt shingles are one of the least heavy roofing materials, these are also easy to cut and install. Using a nailing gun or hammer, you place the shingle accordingly and use four to six nails per shingle to taper it to the roof. The installation process is also less pricey than installing other materials.
  • Repairs are less complicated – If you find leaks or have shingles that have blown off your roof, you can fix parts of your roof and not have to re-install the whole thing. This is because a roofer can simply remove the shingles that have taken some damage and replace these with new ones. This is not a simple thing to do if you have a metal roof, for example.

Cons of Asphalt Shingles

Keep in mind, most building materials will have advantages and disadvantages that come with them. Now, let’s talk about some of the drawbacks of asphalt shingles, such as:

  • Not the most durable material roof option – The age of asphalt shingles ranges from 10-30 years, granted that there are no harsh weather conditions or storms. Asphalt shingle roofs are not as durable or last as long as other roofing options, for example, metal. Metal roofs can last for 50 years plus.
  • Shingles can be easily damaged – When there are multiple periods of high winds in Indianapolis, shingles can be ripped or blown off your roof after constant wear. If these shingles are not taken care of, it can lead to water coming in and this can cause leaks in your home.
  • Fluctuating temperatures can wreck havoc – Because asphalt shingles are not very thick, they are prone to cracking under a lot of pressure. For example, when the seasons are changing, there are periods of temperature fluctuations and asphalt shingles will start to expand during the warm temperatures. In contrast, they will contract when the climate starts to drop, resulting in the shingles cracking.
  • There are limitations to when you can install the shingles – Asphalt shingles are normally installed during spring to late fall, when temperatures range between 40*F-90*F. Any temperature outside of this and there could be some issues. Shingle installations should not occur when the temperatures are extreme, period. This can cause the adhesives on the shingles to refuse to seal properly. Thus, your roof will not be properly closed. During extremely hot temperatures and if the installers are not careful, the shingles can crack when they step down.
  • There are better energy-efficient options – While asphalt shingles are more economical than the other options, they are not the most energy-efficient. They will not cut down on your electrical or heating bill like metal options or green roofs will. If you want to take a look at some better energy-efficient options, read our article here.

asphalt shingle damage- wrinkled shingles

The Bottom Line

Of course, these are just some of the benefits and drawbacks of shingle roofing. Talk to your Indianapolis roofer to understand in further details what the best option for your roof is always beneficial. They will not only be able to answer all your questions, but provide important advice that you can take into account when making final decisions. No one is more versed and prepared to provide this information than your roofing contractor. They work with asphalt every time they step a foot outside of their office. Your selected Indianapolis roofer will also provide sample colors, warranty information and more.

Your Trusted Asphalt Shingle Roofer in Indianapolis

If you need to reach out to a roofing contractor in Bloomington, Indianapolis, Fishers or nearby, then contact us. Having been in business since 2003, Oscar Roofing is your reliable roofer! Operating as a family owned business, we strive to provide the best care for our customers and help them achieve their house goals. Give us a call at (812)545-1381 or (317)358-6625 for a free inspection. Read our reviews here!


Our Roofing Services:

Owens corning preferred contractor review